West Bengal Govt Admits to Mistakes in Including Muslim Castes in OBC List
In a significant development, the West Bengal government has agreed that it had included certain Muslim castes within the list of Other Backward Classes in breach of the guidelines of the Supreme Court. Such an admission has been made in an affidavit before the Supreme Court, The Times of India reported on Thursday. It is being questioned in the backdrop of the recent judgment of Calcutta High Court that trashed the OBC status to several castes, majorly of Muslim groups in the state.
Government Stand and Affirmation
The West Bengal government, in its reply to the Supreme Court, has defended the induction of 77 castes into the list of OBCs. Inclusion in the empowered committee is based on three-tire comprehensive processes through two surveys and a hearing by the Commission for Backward Classes. Some of these Muslim communities were also included in the OBC list in less than 24 hours, and in some cases much before the applications were officially submitted.
This has also thrown the entire process of determining OBC status into doubt over questions of integrity and called in higher levels of scrutiny by civil society and even the judiciary to monitor it.
Supreme Court Hearing and Appeals
The state government of West Bengal has sought an urgent hearing in the Supreme Court pertaining to its appeal against the order of the Calcutta High Court, which it had canceled the OBC status of most of the castes, specifically Muslim communities, saying that the reservations being provided in public sector jobs and other institutions were illegal.
Kapil Sibal, senior advocate for the state government, pleaded that the HC order be stayed as it was hurting the admission process of candidates who have passed the NEET-UG 2024 test. The Supreme Court has agreed to hear pleas by the state on August 27.
High Court Judgment and Its Fallouts
One of the most affected subjects by the declaration of the May 22 judgment of the Calcutta High Court, for West Bengal, has been OBC reservations. According to the verdict, the status of OBCs awarded to castes from 2010 has been termed illegal. It had faulted the then Left Front government’s decision to include 77 Muslim castes as OBCs—something that the court drew is an inference for appeasement of them for political gains rather than for any social and economic backwardness.
The bench stated that this kind of inclusion of such castes made it look like a process to make a vote bank and the process seemed to directly target and have an adverse effect on the rights and liberties of the Muslim Community. While at this, the high court had also reiterated that reservation for those included in the list was religion-wise, which could not be done.
Controversy Over the Process
The HC order at best had questioned the procedural anomalies in bringing those castes within the ambit of the OBC list: it had pointed to flaws such as insufficient consultation with the WB Backward Classes Commission and using reports which do not have the stamp of legal validity. The HC quashed the OBC status of 37 castes because of their failure to follow the requirements of proper consultation.
The court clearly mentioned that the services of all those people who belong to these affected castes, who are already employed or have taken its benefit of reservation, would not be affected. This was done to avoid the disturbing the lives of those people who have already used the facility given by reservation system.
Future Directions and Political Repercussions
The future of OBC classification and reservation in West Bengal, therefore, hangs in the balance pending a hearing by the Supreme Court. More generally, it affects the way in which caste classification is treated and threshed out these days from political and social standpoints.
At one level, this controversy has further underlined the acute necessity and urgency of more rigid and clear procedures in the determination of OBC status for the state to avoid a whole range of legal and political pitfalls, and, on the other level, of experiences of thousands of students who pin their hopes for a better life. Since the matter is sure to be heard before the Supreme Court, which will also ultimately listen to the state’s appeal, this judgment could prove important in the state’s reservations and caste classification scenario.
Conclusion
The acceptance on the part of the government of West Bengal with respect to there existing certain procedural irregularities pertaining to the classification of the castes of Muslims in the OBC list has raised several issues and legal analysis. In this background, the Supreme Court decision is expected to touch upon these issues and could, therefore, change the face of reservation policies in West Bengal. As the case continues against the order of the West Bengal government, legal proceedings and orders that emanate from these will be followed with much interest for the people and entail consequences for the affected communities as well as for the larger reserve system.
Read more about related article, just click here
