West Bengal Doctors Spurn Mamata Banerjee’s Call to Return to Work Amid Ongoing Protests
In what turned out to be a significant development on August 28, 2024, protesting doctors in West Bengal have refused to yield to the call of Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee for returning to work. The decision of doctors came after an appeal from the Supreme Court and a direct request by the Chief Minister, who asked them to go back to work so that the patients can receive the medical attention that they need. However, the doctors said that their demands must be met first before they can think of calling off their strike.
Appeal by Chief Minister to Doctors to Resume Work
West Bengal Chief Minister, Mamata Banerjee, on Sunday, made a fervent appeal to the striking doctors to return to their posts at a programme of Trinamool Congress. She referred to the Supreme Court’s request for drawing her attention as to how strike is affecting people’s health, especially the poorer sections that cannot afford private healthcare.
“The Supreme Court has asked junior doctors to get back to work. Lots of people are dying without treatment; they are poor people, they cannot afford expensive private healthcare,” Banerjee said. Her comments reflected the dire need for medical personnel in government-run hospitals to return to their jobs and end the agony of patients that had been bereft of sufficient medical attention since the strike began.
Banerjee said that the state government could take action against striking doctors as per a Supreme Court order, which empowers state governments to take actions in such situations. She also issued a strong warning that filing an FIR against the protesting doctors could affect their futures, including problems getting passports and visas.
“To date, we have not taken any action against you. I understand that you have grievances and demands, you want justice but now you need to slowly get back to work,” Ms. Banerjee added, in what seemed to be a mix of reassurance and veiled warning.
Protesters Stand Firm, Cite Unmet Demands
Despite an appeal from the Chief Minister, protesting doctors on Saturday ruled out resuming work without their one-point demands being met. In a protest rally taken out in Kolkata, the agitating doctors expressed dissatisfaction with Banerjee’s speech, claiming that instead of addressing their demands, she had issued covert threats to them.
A doctor who participated in the rally at Shyambazar said Banerjee’s remarks accusing the doctors of not informing the government of its decision to call off the strike “means a threat that she will take revenge”. He said, “We will join work but the government has to come out with positive steps before that over our demands.”.
“We have demanded the resignation of Commissioner of Police Vineet Goyal. Former principal Sandip Ghosh has not been arrested or suspended, he is just shuttling between the CBI and ED offices. Why so much delay in suspension of Ghosh? The culprits of rape and murder have not been caught till now, and people who tried to save the evidence have not been arrested,” he said. These demands are being flagged by the doctors, especially in regard to the recent rape and murder case at the R.G. Kar Medical College.
Another protesting doctor from R.G. Kar Medical College and Hospital expressed his disappointment over the approach taken up by the Chief Minister. He reiterated, “We have been saying that we will go back to work when the government takes positive steps toward addressing our demands on safety, accountability, and justice.”
Underlying Issues: Safety, Accountability, and Justice
The continuation of protests by the doctors in West Bengal is rooted in a series of incidents which have shown grave pointers to safety, accountability, and justice. The heinous rape and murder of a postgraduate trainee doctor from R.G. Kar Medical College have raised widespread outrage among the medical fraternity. The doctors accused the government and law enforcement agencies of failing to take effective timely action against the culprits.
Besides, the safety and protection of health professionals working in the state have been viewed as a major issue. The doctors want better measures to keep them safe from incidents of violence and harassment. The failure to take action against those involved has further increased the mistrust and frustration of the doctors, who feel that the safety and well-being of doctors amount to naught before the authorities.
The Road Ahead: Dialogue and Resolution
With the standoff between protesting doctors and the West Bengal government continuing unabated, the prime concern now centers around a resolution that will take into consideration the grievances of the medical fraternity while ensuring the patients receive the necessary medical attention. Doctors have kept it clear that they do not refuse to resume work, provided they get assurances that their demands will be fulfilled.
The government also faces the challenge of upholding law and order amidst legitimate concerns being aired by the healthcare professionals. Meaningful engagement in dialogue with the protesting doctors and visible steps to take up their grievances will be imperative in moving out of the impasse.
Conclusion: Seeking Common Ground for the Sake of Healthcare
The strike by West Bengal doctors not to return to work has brought to the fore deep-seated problems in the state’s health care system and the hassles health professionals have to face in the course of discharging their duties. While the government appeal to the doctors to return to work emanates from immediate necessity of providing medical care to the people, the fundamental issues that prompted the strike should be realistically recognized and addressed.
What is now required is a positive dialogue between the government and protesting doctors that should provide a mutually agreeable solution. Meeting the demands of the doctors regarding safety, accountability, and justice will not only help in resolving the current crisis but also strengthen the healthcare system in West Bengal and ensure that both doctors and patients are safe and secure.
To read more about the related article, click here