Maharashtra Pushes for Higher Non-Creamy Layer Income Limit Ahead of Elections
In the run-up to the crucial Maharashtra Assembly elections scheduled just months ahead, the Eknath Shinde-led Maharashtra Cabinet today took an important decision to table an ordinance seeking the Centre to raise the non-creamy layer income limit. The proposal would attempt to raise the benefits access under the OBC category from increasing the income cap up to the existing amount of Rs 8 lakh per year up to Rs 15 lakh per year. This proposal falls in line with the state’s long-term and short-term strategy to meet the demands of citizens for more inclusive eligibility criteria, and at the same time respond to the on-going changes in socio-economic parameters of the state.
Expansion of Reservation Access: The Proposal
Thursday, October 10, 2024 was the date of the Cabinet meeting that resolved to push through an income limit increase. That marks the focus of the ruling coalition on social justice policies ahead of the polls. The upward revision of the income limit may bring many more OBC individuals under the reservation benefits umbrella. It will help them avail of educational benefits, government services, and other initiatives formulated for uplifting deprived sections of society.
The term ‘non-creamy layer’ is currently used for all such OBCs whose family income does not exceed Rs 8 lakh annually. At this very limit, they are eligible for reservations in myriad sectors. This cap of Rs 7.5 lakh has been a matter of increasing inflation and prices, and that is why many different sections of society have said that this is not enough for today and excludes some of the most deserving candidates for the particular cost of providing the benefits. The state government enhanced the limit to Rs 15 lakh with the objective of redressing some of these grievances while attempting to expand the ambit of the benefits of reservation.
Another intriguing feature of the Cabinet decision is its intent: that many from the disadvantaged communities ought to enjoy the fruits of affirmative action benefits, particularly those falling into the categories above the present income threshold and are hardly rich. It is sure to resonate with many voters when Maharashtra goes to the polls towards the end of the year.
De-divestifying Disparities
Here is a response to burgeoning calls for the review of eligibility criteria in raising the income limit for the non-creamy layer of beneficiaries. Economic gaps are widening increasingly, and ever-larger sections of society clamour for reservations-those whose economic conditions may not be perceived to fall within the traditional definition of poverty but do face stiff barriers to upward mobility.
It is well aware of the changing economic realities most OBC families face. Over the past few years, inflation added to education and healthcare cost increases had pushed several middle-class families to the edge. Several rightly argue that the Rs 8 lakh limit excludes deserving individuals who still require such government support for better opportunities.
It is in the greater trend of the rest of the country, where the pace of debate for expansion of reservation benefits has been really accelerating with changes in times of economy. By taking up such issues, the Maharashtra government is indeed making its correct strategic play to strengthen its OBC voter support and garner them as required for the forthcoming elections.
Empowering the Maharashtra State Scheduled Caste Commission
Besides the measure to hike the limit of non-creamy layer income, one among the important steps taken by the Maharashtra Cabinet are strengthening the Maharashtra State Scheduled Caste Commission. The draft ordinance approved by the Maharashtra Cabinet in the same meeting went on to give constitutional status to the commission, which was the long-pending demand from Dalit organizations and other social justice activists.
It will significantly confer constitutional status on the commission, which will make it more potent for the protection of the rights and interests of the Scheduled Castes in Maharashtra. As things stand now, the bill is likely to be introduced in the next session of the legislature. An ordinance can be enacted declaring it a more potent institution with locus standi and the powers to investigate and take cognizance of incidents of discrimination, exclusion, and violation of rights by Dalits.
Part of commission strengthening is the sanctioning of 27 new posts that will heighten its capacity to redress grievances, as well as other policies designed to advance social justice. The guts to pass this ordinance illustrate government intent to be sensitive to the concerns of marginalized groups and ensure that their voices are heard.
Political Implications Pre-Election
Coming so closely to the Maharashtra Assembly elections, the timing could not be worse. The ruling coalition-the BJP, Shiv Sena with the Shinde faction, and NCP with Ajit Pawar faction-will apparently drive hard to consolidate its voter base ahead of the polls. All these moves–pressure to raise the income ceiling of the non-creamy layer, and a change to empower the Scheduled Caste Commission–are as much gestures to OBC voters as they are to Dalit voters, both key voting blocs in the state.
Indeed, a sensitive and highly politicized issue in the state of Maharashtra – reservation and affirmative action. Steps which are proactive towards the expansion of the ambit of benefits of reservation do seem to be what it takes to make the government look responsive to the needs of the electorate and committed to promoting social equality, which is going to strike the chords of OBC and SC voters who are demanding it.
However, most will be opposed to this proposition to raise the income cap of the non-creamy layer for the simple fact that further extension of the creamy layer can weaken the impact of reservations and will bring more rich families into the list. Also, the step can be viewed as fiscally disadvantageous on both the state budget and public services.
Conclusion: Strategic Step to Social Inclusion
Demand received by the centre to hike the income ceiling of Non-creamy layer to Rs 15 lakhs with effect date from September 22, 2021; Maharashtra cabinet decisions to pass an advisory towards the Government of India for increasing its demand to hike the income ceiling of Non-creamy layer from Rs 8 lakhs to Rs 15 lakhs. This will be a strategic step toward broadening the benefits of reservations and thereby to reduce economic inequalities among the OBC groups. Coupled with this step of making Maharashtra State Scheduled Caste Commission more vigorous, all these steps show that the government is committed to push social justice and inclusion.
These measures will most likely play crucial roles as the state heads into election season, especially among voters from OBC and Dalit communities. Fighting for support of downtrodden communities-the ruling coalition has been addressing long-existing demands for a more inclusive policy and proclaims itself a champion of social equality in the state of Maharashtra.
Read more about related article, just click here
